Conflicted in Paradise Ch. 02

Siara blushed an even more beautiful red, but she eventually nodded. "Kel... put a second finger in my pussy, please," she groaned.

"I'd love to!" Kelsey said happily. She let her index finger slide out of Siara's drenched slit, then put her middle finger next to it and drove both of them back inside in one swift jab. She looked up and giggled at the look of pure joy on Siara's face, then she clamped her mouth back on Siara's cunt, her tongue quickly searching out the little nub.

"Yes... yes, right there! Oh, fucking lick me!" Siara grunted when Kelsey began licking her clit. Her body shivered wildly in Stacey's arms, and Stacey knew she was getting very close to cumming.

"It's a shame a gorgeous girl like you hasn't had sex with other girls before, Siara," Stacey whispered teasingly. She giggled at Siara's happy grin and at how red her face turned.

"Yeah, you have a lot of catching up to do!" Carynne laughed. "Fortunately, we're more than happy to help!"

"Do it, Carynne," Kelsey said excitedly.

Carynne almost immediately shot into action, getting up on her knees and sliding her tongue in the crack of Siara's ass. Before Siara could even respond, Carynne's tongue jabbed inside her asshole.

"Fuck!" Siara yelped as a tremendous shiver tore through her body. "Eat me, you dirty sluts!"

Kelsey and Carynne both laughed happily, then continued feasting on Siara's cunt and ass. Without asking, Carynne shoved another finger inside Siara's pussy, besides Kelsey's two, and together they mercilessly fingered and licked the tall girl towards her climax.

Kelsey felt Amanda kneel behind her, and she shivered with delight at the feel of her lover's tongue caressing her cheek. Amanda's hands began fondling her tits, then they teasingly squeezed her nipples.

"She's right you know," Amanda whispered. "You are a little slut."

"Mmmm-hmmm," Kelsey moaned, continuing to lash her tongue over Siara's clit for a few seconds. "And you all love it!"

Amanda smiled, and Stacey quickly chimed in, "We do! We love that you're our fucktoy, Kel."

"Yes. I love you, my little fucktoy," Amanda breathed. Nibbling on Kelsey's earlobe, she whispered, "And I've missed you."

Kelsey pulled herself away from Siara's cunt and turned towards Amanda. Their mouths met in an eager kiss, and Amanda moaned at the taste of Siara's cunt on Kelsey's tongue.

"I've missed you too," Kelsey said softly. Her eyes shone with her love, and she gave Amanda a beautiful smile.

"Make her cum," Amanda said, nodding her head at Siara.

Kelsey didn't need to be told twice, quickly turning her attention back to Siara's slit. "Are you ready to cum, Siara?" she asked teasingly.

Siara moaned deliriously, quickly pulling Kelsey's face back towards her pussy. Kelsey gave an excited little giggle, then continued sucking Siara's cunt.

Amanda slid her hand underneath Kelsey's skirt and sought out her lover's cunt. She let out a small sigh of delight when she felt how wet Kelsey was, and she quickly slipped two fingers inside that incredible pussy. Kelsey moaned in Siara's cunt when her own pussy was penetrated, but she kept her mouth locked on that tasty slit.

"Cum for us. We want you to cum for us, baby. Cum, cum, cum!" Stacey starting chanting in Siara's ear, her hands still continuously tweaking and squeezing the British girl's tits.

"Oh God... I'm almost there. More, please. More!" Siara whispered. She was shivering with delight at the two tongues that were penetrating both her holes, and her entire brain was wallowing in a sea of lust at the mere thought of a girl's tongue being shoved inside her asshole. Stacey was tightly holding on to her while continuously playing with her tits and sucking on her neck.

"What else do you want, baby?" Stacey asked.

"Put a finger in my bum, please!" Siara moaned.

Carynne grinned victoriously, quickly bringing up her other hand and sliding a finger inside the tight little asshole she was already tonguing. She drove it deep in a single stroke and slid it forward until it was buried to the knuckle. She quickly timed her strokes with the fingers plowing inside Siara's cunt and started happily penetrating both the sexy girl's holes, loving the tight, clenching feeling.

"Fuck!" Siara screamed. She bucked wildly in Stacey's grasp, the continual caresses and actions from the three horny girls too much for her to resist any longer. Her entire body felt like it was on fire, and a white flash of light exploded inside her brain.

"Here she goes!" Stacey laughed delightedly. She took Siara's earlobe between her teeth and bit down on it quite hard. "Cum for us!"

Kelsey's tongue was flashing like crazy against Siara's clit, and she quickly pulled her fingers out, wanting to taste every drop of cum. She moved her mouth forward to clamp it over Siara's cunt, but before she could get there, a huge spray of juice burst out of that delicious slit, splattering all over her face.

Kelsey gasped in complete surprise, and she could hear Amanda's surprise right behind her. Then, as the second squirt of Siara's cum washed over her, she began to laugh with sheer joy. Placing her face just an inch away from Siara's squirting cunt, she let every drop of juice soak her face and her hair.

"Oh fuck... God! Fuck, Christ!" Siara squealed as gush after gush of cum shot out of her twitching cunt, splattering all over the gorgeous brunette in front of her. Her orgasm was more powerful than any she'd ever had before, and she had to fight to stay conscious while her body just kept detonating.

Carynne was still plowing away in Siara's ass, grinning at the sight of her girlfriend getting drowned in cum.

Amanda's fingers were blurring in Kelsey's pussy, and her heart was hammering in her chest at the sight of another girl drenching Kelsey's face. Finally, she wasn't able to resist any longer. She put her cheek against Kelsey's and stuck her tongue out, moaning when a small squirt of Siara's delicious cunt juice splashed on it.

Stacey was still laughing as Siara came over and over again, and she securely held her through her orgasm. Finally, with a long, deep moan, Siara slumped in Stacey's arms, her massive cum having completely overwhelmed her.

As soon as the gorgeous British girl finished cumming, Kelsey let herself go. She'd just been used by three girls, having had her face drenched by all of them, and her brain was practically melting. Amanda's fingers in her pussy touched all the right spots, as always, and she clenched her cunt down on them, then she came.

Amanda softly nibbled on her cheek as her orgasm washed through her, and her powerful squirts of juice sprayed out of her cunt, soaking Amanda's fingers. Her orgasm wasn't as long-lasting as Siara's, but it was no less intense, and finally Kelsey sank on her back on the floor, completely satisfied.

Carynne stopped playing with Siara's ass and quickly scooted over to Kelsey, lying down on top of her and giving her several deep kisses. Amanda joined them, and the three of them moaned as they kissed lazily.

After a few moments, Kelsey started giggling. It quickly grew to a crescendo, and Carynne and Amanda joined in a few seconds later, to be followed by Stacey and finally Siara.

"That was so awesome!" Kelsey squealed.

"Yes, it was. I came so hard. But I'm so sorry, Kelsey," Siara said, between deep gasps of air.

"Don't be sorry! I loved it!" Kelsey grinned, knowing immediately what Siara was apologizing for.

"You did?"

"Of course! I've been squirting on all of their faces for almost two years. I love it that someone finally did it to me!" Kelsey said excitedly. Then she quickly turned towards Amanda. "I love your squirts, honey, you know I do, but—"

"I know," Amanda grinned. "I don't squirt like that. I'm glad someone finally got to show you just how unbelievably hot it is."

The two of them smiled at each other.

"Wow. I always thought people would be disgusted by it if I did that," Siara said softly, partially in amazement and partially in obvious joy.

"Not us!" Stacey grinned. "We absolutely love it!"

"Oh my God!" a new voice suddenly said from behind all of them. They all turned and saw the gorgeous shop girl standing in the entry-way with an astonished look on her face. "What are you doing?!"

Before anyone could reply, Carynne quickly got to her feet. "What does it look like we're doing?" she grinned. She took the girl's hands in her own. "Sorry, we got a little horny."

"Yeah, I... I can see that!" the girl stuttered. "But you can't do this in my shop! Customers will hear you! You were loud enough that they might have heard you on the street!"

"Then how about you close up for an hour or so?" Carynne said amicably.

"An hour?!" the girl gasped.

"Oh, you want to go for more? How about two hours then?"

Stacey couldn't help herself, and she giggled loudly at Carynne's audacity. The girl was looking at Carynne as if the small brunette had grown horns, then she started giggling.

Carynne was still giving the shop girl a challenging grin. "Well?"

The girl looked around at all the gorgeous, mostly naked bodies on display, and she hesitated for just a few seconds, then she nodded.

"You can't be serious? You're going to fuck her too?" Siara gasped at Carynne.

"Of course. Why not? She's really fucking hot!" Carynne said with obvious enthusiasm, leering at the girl. "I'd love to fuck her."

"But... I... oh my God! You girls are unbelievable!" Siara stammered. Both she and the shop girl had a similar, confused expression on their faces.

"Unbelievably sexy, or unbelievably bad?" Stacey grinned.

"Both!" Siara said. She maintained a stunned expression for another second, then she began laughing again.

The sound of the bell from the front door cut through everyone's elatedness, and the shop girl's face fell with disappointment. She quickly ran through the small corridor and yelled, "I'll be right with you!" She returned to the group in the fitting room and sighed. "It's a large group of people. I'm afraid it will be quite awhile before I'm done with them. I'm sorry."

"Me too," Carynne said. She quickly gave the shop girl a kiss, then watched her walk off. The pout on her face made Kelsey giggle.

"Awww, poor baby. Now you can't fuck the hot shop girl!" Kelsey grinned.

"I know!" Carynne said petulantly. She kept up her charade a few more seconds, then she giggled, "I guess I'll just have to fuck you then."

Kelsey's smile was truly gorgeous, and the girls quickly got back up and put their clothes back in order. The remainders of girl-cum were licked off Kelsey's face, with Siara being the most eager participant; then, they all trooped out of the fitting room, merely grinning at the stares from a surprised couple. Carynne and Siara went to the cash register where they paid for their bikinis, and Carynne gently put her hand on the shop girl's, as if to say how sorry she was that they didn't get to fool around before they all left.

As they were walking back towards the town square, where presumably Damon and Ryan were still playing Bossa Ball, Kelsey pulled Amanda and Carynne aside, letting Stacey and Siara walk ahead for about half a block.

"That was amazing. Thank you, Amanda. I loved tasting your pussy again!" Kelsey said with a giant smile of happiness.

"Yeah, I'm so glad you joined us again!" Carynne chimed in, giving Amanda a big smooch on her cheek. "I missed you like crazy."

Amanda gave them a small smile. "I loved it too, from both of you," she said, though she was unable to keep the hesitation out of her voice.

As always, Kelsey picked up on it immediately. "What's wrong?"

"It's just... I'm just worried what Damon will say."

Kelsey frowned. "What do you mean?"

"Well, I had sex with you and Carynne..."

"Yeah, and I'm glad you did. I never wanted to suggest to you guys that we should let Carynne join us, since I knew you were so adamant about your exclusivity, but I'm glad you did. And I know Carynne is too!" Kelsey said, blowing a kiss at her girlfriend, which Carynne responded to in kind.

Amanda hung her head, and she fiercely bit her lip, right at the same spot where she'd bitten it several nights before. It immediately started bleeding again.

"Oh my God, Amanda!" Kelsey squeaked when she saw it. "Why did you do that?"

Amanda looked back up, tears in her eyes. "Damon... he..."

"What?" Carynne asked, taking Amanda's hand in her own and squeezing it in comfort and support.

"He doesn't know... what I just did..."

Both Kelsey and Carynne looked at each other for a second, their smiles turning into worried looks. "You mean you two didn't talk about letting me join Kel when she goes to be with you?" Carynne asked.

Amanda just shook her head.

Kelsey wrapped her arms around Amanda and pulled her close, feeling her heart sink when Amanda started to cry. "He'll be okay, you know that. He can never stay angry at you," Kel said encouragingly.

Amanda just sniffled and appeared to nod, though Kelsey wasn't sure.

"Why did you do it then, if you hadn't talked with Damon about it?" Carynne asked her sympathetically.

"Stacey... she convinced me to," Amanda whispered softly. "She told me what you were doing, and I remembered how awesome it had been in Stars, and I just couldn't resist joining..."

Both Kelsey's and Carynne's eyes turned towards Stacey, who was a good fifty yards ahead of them and was laughing happily at something Siara had said. Carynne's look was questioning, but Kelsey's was one of complete irritation and anger.

"I think I need to have a long talk with Miss Winterton," Kelsey said darkly.

To be continued...

***** ***** *****

Thanks for reading! If you enjoyed the chapter, please either leave a comment or send me some feedback. I love hearing from my readers, and if you leave me a valid email address, I always write back. :)