It's Only Fair Pt. 02

Before the twins could say anything more, Amy stood up from her chair and pulled down her panties. She sat back down, spread her legs, and exposed her amazing pussy to the room. Then my older sister dropped her hands down to her snatch and started to stroke herself.

It was amazing, it was awesome. Incredible to see someone as hot as my older sister bringing herself to her own peak. But I couldn't help but wonder why Amy had put herself in this position.

Amy looked at the rest of us accusingly and I understood. It was totally worth jumping if it forced the rest of us over the cliff as well. I took off my boxers and by the time I looked up, I saw that the twins were now bottomless, as well.

In that environment, three beautiful girls all rubbing themselves, I didn't need to be coerced to start working myself. Still I took my time, teasing. Amy seemed to be doing the same. But Brianna and Jenna hadn't gotten the memo, because they both were really going at it.

The girls' hands went so fast they were almost a blur. Brianna digging into her blonde snatch, Jenna with her bare one. Jenna's face flushed. Brianna grunted in a very un-girly way. My younger twins jammed their slots until it seemed like they were both about to hit the jackpot, then...

"Stop!" Amy yelled.

My older sister had to physically separate my sisters from their pussies, lifting their arms away like she'd done the night before.

"You two really need to get a hold of yourselves," Amy said. The twins looked up at us sheepishly. "Well, stop getting a hold of your... Anyway. I think it's Jen's turn."

The brunette knew better than to hesitate, lest Amy take her turn away from her, too.

"I sucked my brother's cock," Jenna said. She covered her mouth, as if she couldn't believe the words had come out of her. I think she was trying so hard to be quick (also was so drunk), that she wasn't able to be smart.

I, on the other hand, couldn't have been happier. I leaned back on the couch, arms behind my head. My dick stuck straight up. I mean, of course it did. Sure, I'd blown my load four times already in a 24-hour period. But I was surrounded by three naked women, had just been rubbing myself, and my sister had announced I was about to get oral. A eunuch would get erect after all that.

"We'll do it together, Bree," Amy said, looking not at all disappointed. My older blonde sister knelt and grabbed my dick -- fuck that felt nice -- and held it in place. Then my younger blonde sister got down next to her and tentatively licked up my shaft. "Suck, not taste, baby," Amy said, not too unkindly.

Brianna settled herself and took a deep breath. You'd think she was getting ready to swallow a sword, not a cock. She opened her mouth wide and wrapped it around the head of my dick.

"That's a girl," Amy said.

"Mmhmm," Brianna said, making wet smacking noises now as she bobbed up and down on my dong. I could only sit back and luxuriate, eyes half closed as my baby sister did her best on me. I kept wishing Amy would take her turn, but by 'both do it' apparently my older sister really meant 'I'll direct while you drive.'

"Take it deeper now," Amy said, "That's it. Up and down. Careful with your teeth." Jeez it was like my sister had a direct line to my brain. I didn't need to say anything, apparently -- Amy could simply advocate for me. But despite both sisters' efforts, this was more of a turn on in concept than reality. Brianna couldn't get much of a rhythm. I either got pressure or stroking but never both. And so, as spoiled as this sounds, I started to hope we'd move on to something else. Let's see if Amy could hear this next thought.

"OK, Bree, I think that's enough for now," Amy said, gently lifting our younger sister up by her shoulder. Telepathy for the win!

"Did I do OK for you, Chase?" Brianna asked, smiling at me shyly.

"You sucked his dick, that's pretty damn OK," Amy said.

My dick hung hard and slightly cold from my sister's saliva. I was finally able to open my eyes and saw Jenna staring over at me. I couldn't read her expression at all, but she had her hand dipped into her bare puss.

"OK, my turn," Amy said, and clapped her hands. Come on psychic connection!

"I've licked a girl's pussy," Amy said. Oh well, even Miss Cleo misses a few.

"Wow, really?" Jenna asked. "When?"

"Oh, it was a while ago," Amy said, "In college."

"Cool, who with?" Brianna asked.

"Is this story time or sexy time?" Amy asked, but before the girls could answer she continued, "Here we'll pair up. Chase you'll work on me while the twins do each other."

"Wait," Jenna said.

"I don't know," Brianna said.

"I keep telling you two, you're twins so it doesn't count," Amy said, "It's more like... masturbating than doing it with another person. Only you can't lick yourself so it's even better."

Whether our younger sisters bought her argument, Amy clearly didn't care. She got down on all fours and pointed her little pink pussy up at me. I was about to argue that I actually had licked my sister -- Jenna, the night before -- but I decided the argument only worked against me. Why slow things down when I could speed them up? And why exactly was a I fighting against the chance to please my big sister's nearly perfect, golden pussy?

So, I slid off the couch, got my head snatch-level, and started to kiss like I had the night before on Jenna. Amy's vagina was different than her sister's, but all the parts were in the same place, so I did my best to replicate the experience. I'm pretty sure I was, at best, mediocre. But I quickly understood that my performance wasn't the point.

While I'm sure my older sister appreciated the oral attention, Amy's focus was almost solely on our younger sisters. Jenna lay down on her back and Brianna crawled over her.

"So if I," Brianna said.

"Like this," Jenna said.

"And if we?"

"Definitely."

And just like that, the blonde twin had lowered her pussy over her brunette sister's mouth, with her own snatch being lapped at on the other side. The twins started tentatively, much like I was doing with Amy. But they caught on way quicker.

"ffffFFFuck Bree," Jenna said.

"Yes," Brianna said, "Oh yes."

They had two very different styles. Jenna was almost strategic, licking key parts of her sister in a building crescendo. Brianna was all enthusiasm, everything everywhere all the time. The twins reached the same place: a budding, building, inescapable explosion of ecstasy.

The girls were rocking back and forth on the living room floor. Close to achieving their elusive orgasms. Gasping and sighing. I saw Jenna's chest begin to flush.

"Oh... OH!"

"Stop!" Amy said. She jumped forward and practically tackled Brianna to get her off her sister. "Boy you two really liked that didn't you?"

The twins lay on the carpet, gasping like they'd run a marathon. Glaring like they had heat ray vision. Whether it was because of Amy's judgmental comment or simply because she'd kept them from finishing, I can't say. Probably a little of both.

"Your turn, Chase," Amy said. My blonde goddess of an older sister was sitting on the ground, naked. Her blonde pussy peeked out from under her smooth, creamy thighs. Perfect tits hung down.

Jenna and Brianna, my twin younger sisters, were naked on the ground as well. Panting in ways that made their bodies even more desirable. Jenna's taut little body. Brianna's incredible curves. All three sisters stared up at me like they were lost in a world of darkness and my erect penis was the sun.

"Don't be stupid," Amy said.

At least I think she said it. That might have been my own inner monologue. I needed to screw, but I also couldn't screw things up. As before, if I asked for a lot, I might get nothing. If I went for a little, I might get more. But not too little. It was a heck of a puzzle. But, oh, the prize at the end.

My alcohol addled, pleasure pining brain wasn't helping things. All the buildup, my interrupted oral, watching the twins go at it -- my cock was out in the open air and already about to explode. I needed to bury it in a sister soon. The only question was who and where. But I couldn't demand to be fucked, right?

"I played with my sister's breasts," I said dully.

Amy looked at me and sighed, shaking her head in disdain. "Oh for... We're already way past that. No, stupid -- you did Jenna from behind."

"I did," I said.

"Right so now it's Bree's turn," Amy said, "Hop to it, sister." She slapped Brianna's bare bottom. I waited for my younger sister to protest, but instead she simply assumed the position. On all fours, ass pointed upward. A big, happy smile on her face.

"Give it to her good," Amy said.

Jenna sat back, clearly pouting. God, this had gotten so weird. "Brianna always gets to go first," Jenna said.

"You two, I swear." Amy shook her head. Jenna was on her back, crossing and uncrossing her legs. Her eyes dull with drink and wild with desire. "Fine, here, go next to your sister."

Jenna crawled over to Brianna and, dutifully, got on all fours to mirror her twin. Now I had two dripping pussies waiting for me to plug. I walked over. Both twins were smiling at me. I noticed they both still had their socks on. I almost laughed. Well, as Amy had said, socks didn't count.

"Tell your brother what you want," Amy said. She was smiling wickedly. For a moment, it made me think of something, but the concept was fleeting. "Beg for it."

"Please brother, I need it in me," Brianna said.

"Give it to me, fuck your little sister," Jenna said.

"It's wrong to fuck your brother," Amy reminded them both, "It's incest." She let the word slide out of her mouth like she was tasting it. "You little sluts. You're so broken you'd do anything for a dick. Say it."

"I'm a slut," Jenna said, "I'm a needy, horny slut who needs her brother."

"Yes," Brianna said, "We both are. Your sibling sluts. But only for you, big brother. I swear I only want my brother's cock."

"So, you're saying another guy could be in here right now and you would choose your brother instead?" Amy asked.

"Yes," Jenna said.

"Please," Brianna said.

The twins stayed there waiting. Squirming. They looked at each other warmly. Seemed to enjoy the contrast between their two bodies. Brianna's massive melons and upturned ass. Jenna's tiny butt and perky little tits.

Brianna reached over and put her hand on Jenna's. Like they were about to ride the rollercoaster rather than ride their brother's dick.

"You heard your slutty sisters," Amy said, "Now be a good big brother and give it to them."

Like I'd needed any encouragement in the first place. I knelt down, my cock aimed between the two of them. Their mixed scents filled my nose. Strong and sweet. I made a last minute decision and steered my dick over into Jenna's sopping snatch.

"Oh YES!" she cried, a bit of sibling rivalry seeping through. In the interest of being fair, I reached over and started stroking Brianna's pussy while my cock bottomed out in Jenna's.

"How's that?" Amy asked.

"Incredible," all three of us said at the exact same moment.

"There you go," Amy said, "Now remember to be fair to both your sisters."

I pumped in and out of Jenna one more time, then pulled out of her and slid into Brianna. Both of them felt amazing, each different in their own way. The twins watched each other, both whimpering while I worked them. Brianna leaned over and kissed her twin. If I thought they'd been affectionate before, now they were truly like lovers. Urgently pressing their lips together while I fucked them, almost as if it was the twins doing each other. My dick only a prop in their sisterly lovemaking.

"God, Bree, so good," I said.

"Uh huh," Brianna said.

"Fuck, Jenna, so tight," I said, switching back to my other sister.

"SSssssssoooo big," Jenna said.

Every time I filled one sister, I made sure to finger the other. Keeping them both racing towards their ecstasy like some strange, pussy-spinning magic act. And somehow, through all that, I also had the presence of mind to look over the twins' backs and check on Amy. Our older sister was standing, still naked, watching us with this odd look of satisfaction. She smiled and waved me on.

The twins were still kissing. Holding each other's' hand while they rode out the pleasure. Their tits wobbling in time. They looked deep into each other's eyes.

"Our brother," Brianna said.

"Fucking us," Jenna said.

"So good," Brianna said.

"Making... making me cum," Jenna said.

"Me too," Brianna said. She reached over and squeezed Jenna's breasts. "I love your little titties, sis."

Jenna did the same to her twin. "I think yours are so much better."

"Oh! Ffffffffuck our brother's cock is the best," Brianna said.

"Yeah -- ohfuck -- even better when we're both together," Jenna said, "He's pounding your pussy so good. Rubbing my little clitty and... OH FUCK! FUCKING FUCK that's so nice!"

"We're not going to stop are we?" Brianna said, "With Chase. With... with each other."

"Oh fuck no," Jenna said, then to me, "Oh Chase your little sisters love your cock so much! Come on. Give it to us. Give it to meeeeee I need it so bad."

I slid from one pussy to another with ease, like this was at all a natural way to fuck. One, two in Brianna. One, two in Jenna. Bouncing from twin to twin. Oddly, it helped me keep from cumming. God I'd had so much sex the last two days, you'd think my dick would fall off before it could explode again. Instead my dick felt ready to spew any second. Only the little pauses, moving from snatch to snatch, kept me from filling one of the girls once again. Filling. Oh fuck. I started to slow.

Amy seemed to have the same thought, but she had the opposite reaction. "Oooo, your brother is bareback in your unprotected pussies again," Amy said.

"Oh God," Brianna moaned.

"Don't stop," Jenna said.

"You're going to let him cum in you, aren't you?" Amy said, "Your needy cunts are going to suck up your brother's seed. You're going to carry his baby. Slutty sisters knocked up by their brother's spend. Do it Chase. Put your baby in your baby sisters. Do it to them both."

I paused mid-stroke. Waiting for the inevitable. My younger sisters said nothing. Actually, they said something far more surprising.

"Please brother," Brianna said, "Give me your baby."

"Fill me with your seed," Jenna said, "Breed me, brother."

"Oh God. Are you sure?" I asked. I mean, did I want to cum inside my sisters? Hell yeah. But this was... I could barely put together a first thought, but I didn't want the twins having second ones.

"Oh, for Christ's sake," Amy said, "I'm getting the pills. It's not like two batches will be any different than one at this point. Let your little sisters play."

"Please cum in me, I'm gonna cum so hard," Brianna's pussy strained around my cock as she spoke.

"Me first this time," Jenna said, still weirdly competitive about all this. She ground down on my hand. Hot and wet -- it was so hard to let go.

I reached over and strummed Brianna's clit for all I was worth, still pumping her as hard as I could. Our hips slapped like we were trying to hurt each other. Finally, getting stimulated inside and out, Brianna's breathing cut back to gasps. She grunted. Groaned. Turned and stared deep into her twin's eyes.

"Hey Jen? I'm gonna.... Oh God our brother he's gonna... oh FUCK!" Brianna's body went stiff as her orgasm finally ripped through her. Again she pressed her lips to her twin's. The two of them kissed deeply, passionate.

When Brianna's pussy finally unclenched, I slipped out of her and jammed myself in Jenna. Brianna's whole body went limp, but Jenna's tightened like my dick was electric. The sisters were still kissing. Holding each other. Like connecting a circuit of cum.

"Do it," Amy whispered in my ear. I didn't realize she'd gotten so close. "Cum in your little sister's unprotected pussy."

I groaned. If I had any hope of holding out, Amy's words broke right through it. I shot a jet of semen right into my skinny sister.

"Oh, FUCK yes!" Jenna screamed, breaking her kiss with Brianna. Jenna's eyes squeezed shut and her face flushed red. Brianna hugged her sister tight. "My brother's cumming in me!"

I was. Lost in it. In her. The pleasure of my sister's wonderful pussy. The ecstasy that came with cumming inside my little sister. I could barely remember I was supposed to be filling both girls.

"Please..." Brianna groaned, "Want it. Need it."

I quickly pulled out of Jenna and, somehow, entered Brianna before my next explosion. Now my blonde sister stiffened. She shook in her twin's arms.

"He's cumming," Brianna said.

"Cumming in us," Jenna said.

"Sssssooooo good."

I bounced from Jenna to Brianna and back again. Inseminating my sisters one by one. We screamed in orgasmic crescendo. The three of us ripped from reality. Spinning as we all held on tight. In some other-space where nothing made any sense and everything felt right. Amazing. I felt the heat of Jenna's kisses. The reassuring warmth of Brianna's arms around me. All of us staring into each other's eyes, wrapped around each other. Tender and loving together in a way our bodies could no longer hold back. Like all three of us, in that moment, were cumming in each other. Our bodies, our essence. One.

I gasped and fell forward on the cold, scratchy carpet. Finally empty. The twins piled on top of me in a sexual sandwich. All of us still writhing in illicit pleasure, squeezing out the last little bits we could get.

Finally, we slowed, lying there in a sweaty, shaking heap. The last dregs of my spend spilled onto Jenna's arm. I rolled off my sisters. Lay back. My eyes opened slowly, and I saw my older sister staring down at me with a smile.

Brianna and Jenna untangled from each other. They started to giggle.

"Fuck I can't believe we did that," Brianna said.

"Again," Jenna said, "I can't believe we did that again."

"You're never going to stop," Amy said. It wasn't a question.

"I guess we really are your sister sluts," Brianna said to me. She was grinning. She started to stand and a warm glob of my cum dripped out of her pussy and splattered onto her twin's chest. Jenna reached down and scooped it off. She eyed it oddly, then shrugged and slid it inside her own snatch. She shivered a little as she did so.

I picked myself up, legs wobbling and leaned against the couch. Stared out, unfocused -- post sex stupid. My dick lay limply on my thigh.

"You selfish sluts," Amy said, "You broke him before I could have a turn."

I looked up at Amy. She still looked so pleased. That thought I'd had before, it came rushing back to me. Amy's glee at every depraved thing I did with my baby sisters. How she got them to do dirty things with each other. I still didn't understand it, yet somehow it made sense. Like putting the last puzzle piece in with a satisfying click, then standing back and realizing you still have no idea what you're looking at.

Jenna crawled over to me and kissed me hard, on the mouth. Tongue and all. "Thanks, big brother," she said.

Brianna came over and kissed me too. "Thanks for making us feel so good."

Amy looked down at us and grinned. She cocked her eyebrow playfully. "Such a good big brother."

Amy's phone gleeped and she looked down at it. "Mom and Dad will be home in an hour," she said, in a strange, almost professional way. "We need to clean this place up quick. I'll get the alcohol. You three tidy up... Well yourselves, I guess."

The three of us stumbled up the stairs. Still quite drunk and totally fucked out. Brianna and Jenna turned toward their bathroom. I tried to follow them. Ok maybe not totally out. I mean, come on. Naked sisters!

Jenna put her hand on my chest as I tried to go through the doorway.